Landlords Struggle to Navigate Fragmented Rental Regulations, Study Finds

A comprehensive study commissioned by the SafeDeposits Scotland Charitable Trust indicates a significant decline in the ability of private landlords to navigate rapidly evolving rental regulations. The research highlights that systemic fragmentation of information from government bodies and local authorities constitutes the primary barrier to regulatory compliance.

According to the findings, only 41 percent of landlords currently feel capable of keeping pace with legal changes affecting the private rented sector. This represents a substantial decrease from the 51 percent recorded in the Trust’s 2024 Voice of the Landlord Survey. Furthermore, merely 21 percent of respondents believe that legislative modifications are communicated clearly.

The report identifies that landlords frequently rely on a decentralized network of information sources, including government websites, local council guidance, online forums, and informal communications. This fragmented approach significantly elevates the risk of accidental regulatory breaches. Many property owners report that available online information is frequently outdated or contradictory, leading to a false sense of compliance.

Dr. Jennifer Harris, Head of Policy at SafeDeposits Scotland, stated that the current communication infrastructure is inadequate for the regulatory demands placed on housing providers.

“Providing homes in the private rented sector is a significant responsibility, and landlords should have the support and clarity needed to meet the standards that are rightly expected of them,” Dr. Harris said. “However, this research shows many landlords who are trying to do the right thing are struggling to navigate what has become an increasingly complex and fragmented system. Too often, landlords are piecing together information from multiple sources and hoping they have not missed something important.”

The research indicates that the majority of landlords are motivated by a desire to provide safe housing accommodations rather than a fear of punitive enforcement action. However, systemic barriers, including complex compliance rules, escalating operational costs, and a shortage of qualified tradespeople for essential repairs, impede their ability to meet statutory obligations.

To address the compliance deficit, the SafeDeposits Scotland Charitable Trust has recommended the establishment of a centralized, single-source online hub containing all current private rented sector regulations. Additional recommendations include the expansion of practical compliance tools, such as standardized templates and checklists, alongside targeted financial support to assist property owners in meeting forthcoming energy efficiency standards.

The report’s publication coincides with anticipated regulatory expansions within the Scottish housing market, including proposed rent control mechanisms and enhanced environmental compliance requirements affecting over 330,000 households within the private rented sector.